Contents
- Facts and Procedural History of the Ritter Sport Case
- Key Findings of the Stuttgart Higher Regional Court
- Context: Registrability and Enforcement of 3D Marks
- Why packaging shapes rarely become trade marks
- The hurdle of “pure shapes”
- The enforcement hurdle
- Conclusion: Practical Recommendations for Businesses
May an oat bar be sold in square packaging with side flaps if it is reminiscent of Ritter Sport? No, says the Stuttgart Higher Regional Court (judgment of 5 November 2026, case no. 2 U 3/26), overturning the contrary judgment of the Regional Court. The decision shows how far the protection of a well-known packaging shape can extend – and, at the same time, how difficult it is to obtain such a trade mark in the first place.
Facts and Procedural History of the Ritter Sport Case
A company affiliated with the manufacturer of Ritter Sport owns a so-called three-dimensional trade mark (shape mark), registered since 28 August 2001 for, among other goods, chocolate bars. What is protected is not a logo or lettering but the empty, unprinted packaging: a body with a square base, two side closure flaps with a finely serrated edge and a flap running across the back.
Since November 2024, Mannheim-based Wacker GmbH has been selling the organic oat bars “MONNEMer QUADRAT” (cocoa hazelnut and coconut almond) in square packaging with side flaps, inspired – according to the company – by Mannheim’s grid of city blocks known as the “Quadrate”. The bars were advertised, among other things, with the slogan “Quadratisch. Kokos. Klar.” (“Square. Coconut. Clear.”). Ritter Sport sued for injunctive relief, information, damages and recall.
Stuttgart Regional Court (judgment of 13 January 2026, case no. 17 O 192/25): The action was dismissed. Chocolate and oat bars were not sufficiently similar goods. Owing to wider flaps, longitudinal grooves and a coarser zigzag pattern, the bar’s packaging appeared rather rectangular.
In addition, other square confectionery products were on the market, so consumers would not think of Ritter Sport whenever they saw a square. The Regional Court disregarded the slogan because it was not part of the subject matter of the action.
Stuttgart Higher Regional Court (judgment of 5 November 2026, case no. 2 U 3/26): On Ritter Sport’s appeal, the 2nd Civil Senate granted the action in full. A further appeal on points of law was not admitted; however, Wacker may lodge a complaint against non-admission with the Federal Court of Justice and has announced that it will do so. The judgment is therefore not yet final. The full text has not yet been published; the following account is based on the court’s press release and media reports.
Key Findings of the Stuttgart Higher Regional Court
Likelihood of confusion. Courts assess whether consumers may confuse two signs on the basis of three interdependent factors: the similarity of the goods, the similarity of the signs and the strength (“distinctiveness”) of the earlier mark. The Higher Regional Court assessed all three factors differently from the Regional Court:
- Chocolate and oat bars were at least averagely similar goods; both served as a small treat in between meals and targeted the same purchasers.
- The packaging was similar to the registered shape to an above-average degree. The fact that the bar’s packaging was geometrically closer to a rectangle did not change this.
- The Ritter Sport shape mark had a very high degree of distinctiveness; the Senate found no weakening, for instance by other square products.
Protection of marks with a reputation. Marks with a reputation are additionally protected against third parties taking unfair advantage of their reputation or distinctive character without due cause (Section 14(2) no. 3 German Trade Mark Act). In the Senate’s view, the square shape exerts a considerable “pull”, which Wacker deliberately exploited; the company benefited from decades of investment in the mark without having contributed to it.
Role of the slogan. The slogan “Quadratisch. Kokos. Klar.” obviously alludes to “Quadratisch. Praktisch. Gut.” (“Square. Practical. Good.”) and steers consumers’ thoughts even more specifically towards Ritter Sport. Accompanying advertising can thus shape the overall picture of an infringement, even if it is not itself challenged.
No review of registrability. The Higher Regional Court did not examine whether the shape was validly registered as a trade mark. In infringement proceedings, the court is bound by the existing registration, which the Federal Court of Justice has confirmed. The judgment does not impose a general ban on square packaging; what was decisive was the combination of several circumstances in the individual case.
Legal consequences. Wacker may no longer use the packaging and must provide information, pay damages, recall the goods and reimburse legal fees.
Context: Registrability and Enforcement of 3D Marks
Why packaging shapes rarely become trade marks
Consumers generally do not perceive the shape of a product or its packaging as an indication of origin, but simply as packaging. Shape marks therefore often lack distinctive character. The Lindt “Gold Bunny” illustrates this: in 2012, the Court of Justice of the European Union refused registration as an EU trade mark because the rabbit shape, gold foil and red ribbon belong to the customary range of shapes for Easter chocolate (CJEU, judgment of 24 May 2012, C-98/11 P).
Where a sign lacks inherent distinctiveness, it may acquire distinctiveness through intensive use (“acquired distinctiveness”). For EU trade marks, however, this must be proven in all Member States in which the sign was not originally distinctive. This is ultimately what defeated the shape of the “KitKat” bar: proof covering merely a substantial part of the Union is insufficient (CJEU, judgment of 25 July 2018, C-84/17 P et al.). The Ritter Sport marks are also registered on the basis of acquired distinctiveness, but as German marks, for which proof only had to be furnished for Germany.
The hurdle of “pure shapes”
In addition, there are specific grounds for exclusion: shapes that result from the nature of the goods, are necessary to obtain a technical result or give substantial value to the goods are not eligible for trade mark protection (Section 3(2) German Trade Mark Act). Ritter Sport and the manufacturer of Milka litigated this question for more than ten years. In 2017, the Federal Court of Justice clarified that the square shape does not result from the nature of the goods, and in 2020 it held that the shape does not give substantial value to the chocolate either: it has no particular artistic value and does not lead to significant price differences; merely advertising the shape does not change this (BGH, decisions of 23 July 2020, I ZB 42/19).
The enforcement hurdle
Even a registered shape mark does not prevail automatically. On the same facts, the Regional Court and the Higher Regional Court in Stuttgart reached opposite results. Critical issues typically include:
- detailed differences in the challenged shape (proportions, flaps, embossing) and the overall im-pression on a consumer who does not see both products side by side;
- the similarity of goods where the infringer moves into an adjacent product category;
- a possible weakening of the mark through similar shapes used by other market participants;
- proof of reputation, typically through consumer surveys, sales and advertising figures.
The Higher Regional Court’s judgment shows that a very well-known shape mark built up over decades can enjoy a broad scope of protection, even beyond the registered class of goods. For less well-known shapes, the scope of protection is likely to be considerably narrower.
Conclusion: Practical Recommendations for Businesses
Businesses seeking to protect packaging as a 3D trade mark should:
- design the shape early and deliberately so that it clearly departs from industry norms, without emphasising functional or purely aesthetic features;
- file the shape in a neutral representation (without logo) so as to protect the shape itself, while also registering word/figurative marks and, where appropriate, designs;
- use the shape consistently and prominently in advertising and continuously document evidence (sales, advertising spend, market shares, surveys) in order to be able to prove acquired distinc-tiveness;
- for an EU trade mark, plan the evidence for all relevant Member States or opt for national marks in core markets.
Businesses seeking to defend an existing shape mark should:
- monitor the market and take consistent action against imitations, including in adjacent product categories, to prevent the mark from being weakened;
- substantiate reputation and distinctiveness robustly, in particular through up-to-date consumer surveys;
- document the opponent’s accompanying advertising and slogans and, where appropriate, ex-pressly include them in the subject matter of the action.
Businesses launching a new product should:
- have it checked before market launch whether the shape and packaging affect well-known third-party shape marks; a different product name or type of goods does not automatically provide protection;
- refrain from allusions to well-known slogans or designs, as these significantly increase the risk of infringement.
It remains to be seen whether the Federal Court of Justice will hear the case. We will keep you informed and would be pleased to assist you with the filing, defence or risk assessment of packaging designs.